That's awesome that vendors here make and sell toys- I feel like it's better to buy other pet lovers not just corporate business who doesn't seem to know the first thing about animals or seem to care. Like I got into a fight with someone at a small animal place about corn in rat food (that is another soap box entirely though!!) I hope maybe I can make stuff and sell too- I am working on knitting baby toys and blankets for my etsy store but I don't have kids so I dunno what I am doing lol I am better to make fur baby stuff.
I never thought about coin wrappers... now I know what to do with some of those 1/2 $ ones I don't use lol I think I have only ever seen a few .50 pieces in my life. One I wont give up lol... Is there a worry about ink in those? Or in anything? I just know the worries of small animals (I miss my rats- I may pester you for ratty pictures Shawna

)
You did NOT just say cupcake wrappers? ^3^ I am so excited! I have so many of those and I hate passing them up at sales or clearance racks but I just am not that into baking cupcakes. Or I have a sick abundance of left overs I have no reason to use them (Like for the baby shower of my nearly 3 year old niece. I don't think I will be making "It's A Girl!" cupcakes again and if I do I can get more later.) Now I can get them and play! Yay! I just hope she likes them as much as I do...
So far I have baby rings (My mom's keets love hanging off of them and my bun tossed some around but I have many more.) I have some of those coco fiber toys Super Pet made, a few ring toys that my rats never liked I can scrub up. I even have a JW bird toy- again the rabbit wasn't amused with it. Most of the official toys I have now are stock piles or rejects from the rats and rabbit. As far as supplies for new- different woods (dad and I do wood working together), tp rolls, hay, craft paper (the stuff they pack with), sisal rope and twine, a stock pile of craft items like non-toxic paper ropes, wood beads, cocofiber, some crinkle papers and baskets. Bells, shiny rings and balls (the ferrets love those so much it's scary!). I am the type that I do not toss crafting items... I tend to hoard with the thought "I can used that someday..." like my yarn stash lol